Lighting Style: Which one looks better?

[p]I’m currently fine-tuning the lighting for Why's It Getting DARKER?! and I need your eyes on this. My goal is to make the ocean feel as suffocating as possible without losing the terror of what’s right in front of you.[/p][h2]The Comparison[/h2][h2]1. Dev View (Behind the Scenes): 2. In-Game Shots (The Player's Perspective): [/h2][hr][/hr][h2]Which one makes your skin crawl?[/h2][p]I'm open to all criticism - don't hold back! Does the darker look feel more immersive, or do you prefer seeing a bit more of the... "local wildlife"?[/p][p]Drop a comment below with your choice! Thank y'all so much for the support and for helping me shape the feeling of Why's It Getting DARKER?![/p]